EFL Stands Firm as Marc Guehi Ruled Out of Carabao Cup Final vs Arsenal

The EFL has taken a firm stance ahead of the Carabao Cup final at Wembley, decisively rejecting Manchester City’s request to make Marc Guehi eligible for the clash against Arsenal.

Despite strong backing from Pep Guardiola, the league showed no flexibility, confirming that the defender will not be allowed to feature in the final. The decision brings an end to City’s hopes of fielding their January signing on one of English football’s biggest domestic stages.

Manchester City’s Appeal Meets EFL Resistance

According to Sky Sports, Manchester City formally approached the English Football League (EFL) seeking special permission for Guehi to play in the Carabao Cup final. However, the response from the league was swift and unequivocal — the request was denied.

City were fully aware that the situation was complicated by competition rules, yet still attempted to challenge the restriction. The EFL, however, remained resolute, refusing to make any exception.

This means Guehi, who joined City from Crystal Palace in January, will watch the final from the sidelines.

Guehi Misses Out Again Despite City’s Final Qualification

Manchester City booked their place at Wembley with a convincing 3–1 win over Newcastle in the semi-final. Once again, Guehi was absent — not due to injury or tactical rotation, but because of eligibility restrictions already enforced by the EFL.

The defender had also been unavailable for the semi-final tie, and the final decision ensures that his exclusion extends to the showpiece event as well.

Why the EFL Has Ruled Marc Guehi Ineligible

The issue centers on timing and the EFL’s revised Rule 6.4.2.

Under the updated regulation, a player may represent more than one club in the competition only if they are registered before either:

• the close of the winter transfer window, or

• the first leg of the semi-final(whichever comes first)

For Manchester City, that deadline arrived early.

City played the first leg of their semi-final on January 13. While Antoine Semenyo, who joined the club on January 9, met the eligibility criteria and was cleared to play, Marc Guehi completed his transfer later — on January 19.

That six-day difference proved decisive.

Semenyo Cleared, Guehi Blocked

The contrast between the two January signings highlights the strict application of EFL rules.

• Antoine Semenyo: Signed before the January 13 cut-off — eligible and even scored.

• Marc Guehi: Signed after the deadline — ruled ineligible for both the semi-final and final.

The EFL made no distinction beyond the regulation itself, applying the rule consistently despite City’s appeal.

Guardiola Voices Frustration Over EFL Decision

Pep Guardiola did not hide his disappointment following the rejection.

“Why shouldn’t he participate? Why not?” Guardiola said.

“He’s our athlete, we pay his wages… I don’t see the reason he can’t participate in the final.”

While clearly frustrated, the City manager acknowledged that the regulation was unlikely to change. Still, he felt the club had a responsibility to ask — even if the answer was ultimately negative.

EFL’s Position Leaves City No Room for Maneuver

With the EFL standing firm, Manchester City must now adjust their plans once again as they prepare for the final against Premier League leaders Arsenal on March 22.

There will be no late reprieve, no exception, and no rule adjustment. The league’s message is clear: regulations apply equally, regardless of circumstance or occasion.

Final Word: EFL’s Authority Prevails

The EFL’s decision underscores its commitment to enforcing competition rules without compromise. While Manchester City may feel aggrieved, the outcome reinforces the league’s authority and consistency.

For Marc Guehi, it means a frustrating wait continues. For City, it’s a reminder that even elite clubs are bound by the same regulations — and that the EFL is not prepared to bend them, even for a Wembley final.

✅ FAQ Block

❓ Why did the EFL block Marc Guehi from playing the final?

The EFL ruled Marc Guehi ineligible because he was registered after the first leg of the semi-final, violating Rule 6.4.2.

❓ Did Manchester City appeal the EFL decision?

Yes, Manchester City requested permission for Guehi to play, but the EFL rejected the appeal.

❓ Can Marc Guehi play in the Carabao Cup final?

No, the EFL has confirmed that Marc Guehi will not be allowed to play in the Wembley final against Arsenal.

---

---

---